Dissenting Opinions: Football Rankings - 2024 Draft
Ed Birdsall (Talking Points Sports) vs Expert Consensus (All Experts)
Ed Birdsall likes him more
Rank | Player | ECR | Diff. |
---|---|---|---|
27 | Trey McBride ARI - TE | 58 | +31 |
32 | Cooper Kupp LAR - WR | 47 | +15 |
35 | Tank Dell HOU - WR | 49 | +14 |
44 | Malik Nabers NYG - WR | 56 | +12 |
68 | Gus Edwards LAC - RB | 104 | +36 |
70 | Justin Herbert LAC - QB | 89 | +19 |
82 | Caleb Williams CHI - QB | 94 | +12 |
92 | Jonathon Brooks CAR - RB | 135 | +43 |
98 | Brock Bowers LV - TE | 111 | +13 |
106 | Ladd McConkey LAC - WR | 129 | +23 |
110 | Taysom Hill NO - TE | 169 | +59 |
120 | Gabe Davis JAC - WR | 132 | +12 |
133 | Will Levis TEN - QB | 148 | +15 |
134 | Adonai Mitchell IND - WR | 164 | +30 |
141 | Ricky Pearsall SF - WR | 191 | +50 |
145 | Cade Otton TB - TE | 173 | +28 |
146 | J.J. McCarthy MIN - QB | 172 | +26 |
153 | AJ Dillon GB - RB | 175 | +22 |
157 | Tucker Kraft GB - TE | 179 | +22 |
159 | MarShawn Lloyd GB - RB | 192 | +33 |
161 | Keaton Mitchell BAL - RB | 174 | +13 |
167 | Miles Sanders CAR - RB | 184 | +17 |
168 | Troy Franklin DEN - WR | 200 | +32 |
173 | Elijah Moore CLE - WR | 189 | +16 |
176 | Xavier Legette CAR - WR | 201 | +25 |
180 | Ray Davis BUF - RB | 220 | +40 |
181 | Michael Mayer LV - TE | 205 | +24 |
193 | Minnesota Vikings MIN - DST | 208 | +15 |
195 | Isaiah Likely BAL - TE | 210 | +15 |
199 | Ka'imi Fairbairn HOU - K | 217 | +18 |
201 | Jermaine Burton CIN - WR | 215 | +14 |
204 | Kenneth Gainwell PHI - RB | 218 | +14 |
205 | Houston Texans HOU - DST | 221 | +16 |
211 | Chicago Bears CHI - DST | 226 | +15 |
216 | Dustin Hopkins CLE - K | 231 | +15 |
218 | Jamaal Williams NO - RB | 233 | +15 |
219 | Denver Broncos DEN - DST | 242 | +23 |
221 | Jonathan Mingo CAR - WR | 236 | +15 |
223 | Alec Pierce IND - WR | 250 | +27 |
226 | DJ Chark Jr. LAC - WR | 260 | +34 |
231 | Odell Beckham Jr. MIA - WR | 254 | +23 |
234 | Cincinnati Bengals CIN - DST | 269 | +35 |
235 | Jeff Wilson Jr. MIA - RB | 272 | +37 |
236 | Tyler Higbee LAR - TE | 262 | +26 |
238 | Kareem Hunt FA - RB | 268 | +30 |
240 | Devontez Walker BAL - WR | 253 | +13 |
242 | Kadarius Toney KC - WR | 292 | +50 |
245 | Kimani Vidal LAC - RB | 264 | +19 |
246 | Jelani Woods IND - TE | 258 | +12 |
248 | New England Patriots NE - DST | 283 | +35 |
250 | Tyrone Tracy Jr. NYG - RB | 286 | +36 |
252 | Daniel Carlson LV - K | 276 | +24 |
265 | DeVante Parker PHI - WR | 289 | +24 |
268 | Trey Palmer TB - WR | 280 | +12 |
277 | Deuce Vaughn DAL - RB | 290 | +13 |
281 | Blake Grupe NO - K | 293 | +12 |
282 | Greg Dulcich DEN - TE | 309 | +27 |
289 | Emari Demercado ARI - RB | 304 | +15 |
290 | Tyler Scott CHI - WR | 302 | +12 |
291 | Theo Johnson NYG - TE | 319 | +28 |
294 | Erick All CIN - TE | 351 | +57 |
297 | Marquez Valdes-Scantling FA - WR | 322 | +25 |
299 | Austin Hooper NE - TE | 450 | +151 |
304 | Tim Patrick DEN - WR | 406 | +102 |
305 | Jared Wiley KC - TE | 429 | +124 |
306 | Brandon Powell MIN - WR | 414 | +108 |
308 | Cade Stover HOU - TE | 379 | +71 |
311 | Quez Watkins PIT - WR | 440 | +129 |
314 | Kyle Philips TEN - WR | 431 | +117 |
315 | Chase Claypool BUF - WR | 402 | +87 |
316 | Latavius Murray FA - RB | 332 | +16 |
317 | Xavier Gipson NYJ - WR | 404 | +87 |
318 | Keaontay Ingram KC - RB | 342 | +24 |
319 | Foster Moreau NO - TE | 453 | +134 |
323 | Kenny Pickett PHI - QB | 343 | +20 |
324 | Isaiah McKenzie NYG - WR | 438 | +114 |
325 | Johnny Mundt MIN - TE | 410 | +85 |
329 | Frank Gore Jr. BUF - RB | 420 | +91 |
333 | Chris Moore ARI - WR | 419 | +86 |
334 | Ryan Tannehill FA - QB | 447 | +113 |
335 | Darnell Washington PIT - TE | 413 | +78 |
337 | Ty Johnson BUF - RB | 411 | +74 |
338 | Jake Browning CIN - QB | 432 | +94 |
339 | David Bell CLE - WR | 428 | +89 |
340 | Jamison Crowder WAS - WR | 451 | +111 |
341 | Brevin Jordan HOU - TE | 361 | +20 |
343 | Braxton Berrios MIA - WR | 452 | +109 |
344 | Josh Oliver MIN - TE | 442 | +98 |
345 | Cedrick Wilson Jr. NO - WR | 405 | +60 |
346 | Justyn Ross KC - WR | 445 | +99 |
347 | Jameis Winston CLE - QB | 393 | +46 |
348 | Jaheim Bell NE - TE | 362 | +14 |
349 | Parris Campbell PHI - WR | 455 | +106 |
350 | Nick Westbrook-Ikhine TEN - WR | 395 | +45 |
352 | Harrison Bryant LV - TE | 489 | +137 |
354 | Durham Smythe MIA - TE | 443 | +89 |
356 | Jeremy Ruckert NYJ - TE | 374 | +18 |
357 | Kenny McIntosh SEA - RB | 444 | +87 |
358 | Mac Jones JAC - QB | 422 | +64 |
359 | Trayveon Williams CIN - RB | 436 | +77 |
360 | Irv Smith Jr. KC - TE | 412 | +52 |
361 | Terrace Marshall Jr. CAR - WR | 437 | +76 |
362 | Patrick Taylor Jr. SF - RB | 403 | +41 |
363 | Boston Scott LAR - RB | 434 | +71 |
365 | Jase McClellan ATL - RB | 408 | +43 |
366 | Will Mallory IND - TE | 396 | +30 |
368 | Kendall Milton PHI - RB | 449 | +81 |
369 | Mecole Hardman Jr. FA - WR | 388 | +19 |
374 | Cole Turner WAS - TE | 407 | +33 |
375 | Charlie Jones CIN - WR | 415 | +40 |
377 | Tyquan Thornton NE - WR | 418 | +41 |
378 | Jamari Thrash CLE - WR | 391 | +13 |
380 | Kevin Harris NE - RB | 400 | +20 |
383 | Isaiah Hodgins NYG - WR | 439 | +56 |
Expert Consensus likes him more
Rank | Player | Diff. | |
---|---|---|---|
33 | Travis Kelce KC - TE | 49 | +16 |
63 | Christian Kirk JAC - WR | 81 | +18 |
65 | Alvin Kamara NO - RB | 79 | +14 |
91 | Diontae Johnson CAR - WR | 108 | +17 |
101 | Zack Moss CIN - RB | 116 | +15 |
103 | Devin Singletary NYG - RB | 119 | +16 |
115 | Dalton Schultz HOU - TE | 127 | +12 |
116 | Tyler Lockett SEA - WR | 139 | +23 |
117 | Cole Kmet CHI - TE | 130 | +13 |
121 | Jakobi Meyers LV - WR | 136 | +15 |
122 | Deshaun Watson CLE - QB | 138 | +16 |
126 | Chuba Hubbard CAR - RB | 147 | +21 |
140 | Curtis Samuel BUF - WR | 165 | +25 |
143 | Rashid Shaheed NO - WR | 163 | +20 |
147 | Kendre Miller NO - RB | 162 | +15 |
150 | Roschon Johnson CHI - RB | 172 | +22 |
153 | Luke Musgrave GB - TE | 174 | +21 |
157 | Joshua Palmer LAC - WR | 177 | +20 |
159 | Hunter Henry NE - TE | 209 | +50 |
165 | Jaleel McLaughlin DEN - RB | 188 | +23 |
168 | Quentin Johnston LAC - WR | 194 | +26 |
171 | Michael Wilson ARI - WR | 198 | +27 |
178 | Dontayvion Wicks GB - WR | 196 | +18 |
181 | Dameon Pierce HOU - RB | 215 | +34 |
186 | Darnell Mooney ATL - WR | 203 | +17 |
198 | Bryce Young CAR - QB | 241 | +43 |
199 | Ja'Lynn Polk NE - WR | 229 | +30 |
207 | Alexander Mattison LV - RB | 230 | +23 |
211 | Jaylen Wright MIA - RB | 227 | +16 |
223 | Roman Wilson PIT - WR | 261 | +38 |
224 | Malachi Corley NYJ - WR | 285 | +61 |
225 | Javon Baker NE - WR | 302 | +77 |
229 | Noah Fant SEA - TE | 255 | +26 |
232 | Justin Fields PIT - QB | 254 | +22 |
235 | Audric Estime DEN - RB | 259 | +24 |
237 | Bucky Irving TB - RB | 257 | +20 |
239 | Clyde Edwards-Helaire KC - RB | 256 | +17 |
243 | Kendrick Bourne NE - WR | 262 | +19 |
244 | Ja'Tavion Sanders CAR - TE | 258 | +14 |
245 | Darren Waller NYG - TE | 260 | +15 |
248 | Tank Bigsby JAC - RB | 264 | +16 |
249 | Zay Jones ARI - WR | 379 | +130 |
251 | Tyler Boyd FA - WR | 276 | +25 |
256 | Mike Gesicki CIN - TE | 273 | +17 |
261 | Bo Nix DEN - QB | 307 | +46 |
265 | Indianapolis Colts IND - DST | 278 | +13 |
274 | Cedric Tillman CLE - WR | 295 | +21 |
277 | Brenden Rice LAC - WR | 301 | +24 |
287 | Israel Abanikanda NYJ - RB | 309 | +22 |
288 | Jerick McKinnon FA - RB | 322 | +34 |
291 | Michael Carter ARI - RB | 331 | +40 |
305 | Jonnu Smith MIA - TE | 394 | +89 |
308 | Aidan O'Connell LV - QB | 320 | +12 |
311 | Chase Edmonds TB - RB | 336 | +25 |
312 | Detroit Lions DET - DST | 355 | +43 |
316 | Dylan Laube LV - RB | 364 | +48 |
318 | Cam Akers MIN - RB | 342 | +24 |
320 | Logan Thomas FA - TE | 351 | +31 |
328 | Salvon Ahmed MIA - RB | 393 | +65 |
338 | Donald Parham Jr. LAC - TE | 381 | +43 |
340 | Colby Parkinson LAR - TE | 389 | +49 |
345 | Rasheen Ali BAL - RB | 392 | +47 |
346 | Sam Howell SEA - QB | 397 | +51 |
348 | Royce Freeman DAL - RB | 386 | +38 |
355 | Jalen Tolbert DAL - WR | 373 | +18 |
359 | Xavier Hutchinson HOU - WR | 396 | +37 |
364 | Joe Flacco IND - QB | 387 | +23 |
366 | Johnny Wilson PHI - WR | 390 | +24 |
367 | Tanner Hudson CIN - TE | 391 | +24 |
372 | Jauan Jennings SF - WR | 384 | +12 |