Dissenting Opinions: Baseball Rankings

Mick Ciallela (Fantrax) vs Jake Ciely (The Athletic)

Waiver Wire Advice
Mock Draft

Mick Ciallela likes him more

change
Mick Ciallela versus Jake Ciely Rankings
Rank Player Expert Diff.
4 Corbin Carroll (ARI - LF,CF,RF) 19 +15
5 Mookie Betts (LAD - 2B,SS,RF) 22 +17
6 Kyle Tucker (HOU - RF) 18 +12
9 Freddie Freeman (LAD - 1B) 23 +14
14 Bryce Harper (PHI - 1B,DH) 33 +19
15 Trea Turner (PHI - SS) 29 +14
18 Austin Riley (ATL - 3B) 31 +13
20 Rafael Devers (BOS - 3B) 34 +14
22 Francisco Lindor (NYM - SS) 49 +27
23 Ozzie Albies (ATL - 2B) 38 +15
25 Corey Seager (TEX - DH,SS) 46 +21
26 Marcus Semien (TEX - 2B) 42 +16
29 Michael Harris II (ATL - CF) 48 +19
30 Bo Bichette (TOR - SS) 50 +20
33 Gunnar Henderson (BAL - 3B,SS) 60 +27
35 Randy Arozarena (SEA - CF,LF) 55 +20
36 Elly De La Cruz (CIN - 3B,SS) 54 +18
39 Jose Altuve (HOU - 2B) 57 +18
40 CJ Abrams (WSH - SS) 82 +42
43 Adolis Garcia (TEX - CF,DH,RF) 56 +13
47 Jazz Chisholm Jr. (NYY - 3B,CF) 70 +23
49 Nolan Jones (COL - 1B,LF,RF) 77 +28
52 Royce Lewis (MIN - 3B,DH) 76 +24
53 Cody Bellinger (CHC - 1B,CF,DH,RF) 71 +18
54 Manny Machado (SD - 3B,DH) 66 +12
56 Oneil Cruz (PIT - CF,SS) 105 +49
57 Logan Gilbert (SEA - SP) 91 +34
59 Christian Yelich (MIL - LF,DH) 100 +41
61 Gleyber Torres (FA - 2B) FA 74 +13
63 Nico Hoerner (CHC - 2B,SS) 87 +24
64 Paul Goldschmidt (FA - 1B,DH) FA 79 +15
70 Adley Rutschman (BAL - C,DH) 133 +63
71 Bobby Miller (LAD - SP) 94 +23
73 Justin Steele (CHC - SP) 103 +30
75 Christian Walker (FA - 1B) FA 101 +26
76 Lane Thomas (CLE - CF,RF) 131 +55
80 Will Smith (LAD - C) 148 +68
81 Bryan Reynolds (PIT - CF,DH,LF,RF) 93 +12
82 Nick Castellanos (PHI - RF) 108 +26
83 Teoscar Hernandez (FA - DH,LF,RF) FA 95 +12
84 Xander Bogaerts (SD - 2B,SS) 107 +23
85 J.T. Realmuto (PHI - C) 137 +52
91 Andres Gimenez (CLE - 2B) 104 +13
92 William Contreras (MIL - C,DH) 113 +21
93 Yandy Diaz (TB - 1B,3B,DH) 134 +41
97 Evan Carter (TEX - LF,RF) 126 +29
98 Josh Naylor (CLE - 1B,DH) 121 +23
102 Jordan Walker (STL - LF,RF) 127 +25
105 Christian Encarnacion-Strand (CIN - 1B,DH) 123 +18
106 Anthony Volpe (NYY - SS) 168 +62
107 Ha-Seong Kim (FA - 2B,3B,SS) FA 141 +34
108 Ke'Bryan Hayes (PIT - 3B) 163 +55
112 Bryson Stott (PHI - 2B,SS) 149 +37
114 Anthony Santander (FA - 1B,RF,DH) FA 167 +53
116 Thairo Estrada (FA - 2B,SS) FA 194 +78
117 Riley Greene (DET - CF,DH,LF,RF) 173 +56
123 Yainer Diaz (HOU - C,1B,DH) 200 +77
125 Merrill Kelly (ARI - SP) 138 +13
126 Josh Lowe (TB - CF,DH,LF,RF) 182 +56
130 Nick Pivetta (FA - SP,RP) FA 240 +110
132 Hunter Brown (HOU - SP) 161 +29
137 Jarren Duran (BOS - LF,CF) 151 +14
138 Luis Arraez (SD - 1B,2B,DH) 157 +19
139 Esteury Ruiz (ATH - LF,CF,RF) 183 +44
140 Zack Gelof (ATH - 2B) 171 +31
146 Masataka Yoshida (BOS - LF,DH) 186 +40
150 Bryce Miller (SEA - SP) 178 +28
151 Chas McCormick (HOU - LF,CF,RF) 202 +51
153 Isaac Paredes (CHC - 1B,2B,3B,DH) 207 +54
157 Salvador Perez (KC - C,1B,DH) 172 +15
158 Steven Kwan (CLE - LF) 212 +54
160 Willson Contreras (STL - C,DH) 209 +49
161 Aaron Civale (MIL - SP) 254 +93
165 James Outman (LAD - LF,CF) 199 +34
166 Maikel Garcia (KC - 2B,3B,SS) 234 +68
167 Keibert Ruiz (WSH - C) 273 +106
168 Logan O'Hoppe (LAA - C) 237 +69
169 Tyler O'Neill (FA - CF,DH,LF,RF) FA 214 +45
170 Daulton Varsho (TOR - LF,CF) 208 +38
171 Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (ARI - LF,DH) 239 +68
175 Byron Buxton (MIN - CF,DH) 203 +28
176 Cal Raleigh (SEA - C,DH) 216 +40
178 Charlie Morton (FA - SP) FA 198 +20
180 Jonah Heim (TEX - C,DH) 261 +81
183 Taylor Ward (LAA - DH,LF) 210 +27
185 Francisco Alvarez (NYM - C) 213 +28
190 Edouard Julien (MIN - 2B,DH) 248 +58
192 Sean Murphy (ATL - C) 233 +41
194 Triston McKenzie (CLE - SP) 245 +51
195 Starling Marte (NYM - RF) 232 +37
200 Jorge Polanco (FA - 2B,3B) FA 231 +31
201 Gabriel Moreno (ARI - C) 249 +48
205 Nick Lodolo (CIN - SP) 244 +39
208 Brandon Pfaadt (ARI - SP) 267 +59
213 J.P. Crawford (SEA - SS) 236 +23
214 Kenta Maeda (DET - RP,SP) 295 +81
215 Sal Frelick (MIL - CF,LF,RF) 277 +62
217 Kris Bryant (COL - 1B,RF,DH) 241 +24
218 Braxton Garrett (MIA - SP) 285 +67
219 Brandon Drury (FA - 1B,2B,3B,CI,DH) FA 235 +16
221 Luis Rengifo (LAA - 2B,3B,RF,SS) 253 +32
224 Anthony Rizzo (FA - 1B) FA 266 +42
227 MJ Melendez (KC - C,LF,RF) 242 +15
228 Jose Siri (NYM - CF) 258 +30
231 Eugenio Suarez (ARI - 3B) 246 +15
233 Max Kepler (FA - RF) FA 250 +17
237 Mitch Garver (SEA - C,DH) 263 +26
240 Lars Nootbaar (STL - LF,CF,RF) 262 +22
241 Ceddanne Rafaela (BOS - 2B,CF,SS) 259 +18
242 Yusei Kikuchi (LAA - SP) 282 +40
243 Giancarlo Stanton (NYY - RF,DH) 255 +12
246 Brandon Lowe (TB - 1B,2B,DH) 289 +43
250 Justin Turner (FA - 1B,2B,3B,DH) FA 298 +48
251 Vaughn Grissom (BOS - 2B,SS) 272 +21
252 Gavin Williams (CLE - SP) 265 +13
259 Jackson Merrill (SD - SS,CF) 290 +31
262 Will Benson (CIN - CF,LF,RF) 280 +18
265 Ty France (FA - 1B) FA 297 +32
267 Brent Rooker (ATH - LF,RF,DH) 288 +21
272 Kyle Harrison (SF - SP) 284 +12
273 Leody Taveras (TEX - CF) 291 +18

Jake Ciely likes him more

change
Jake Ciely versus Mick Ciallela Rankings
Rank Player Expert Diff.
3 Zack Wheeler (PHI - SP) 21 +18
4 Pablo Lopez (MIN - SP) 37 +33
5 Kevin Gausman (TOR - SP) 34 +29
6 Luis Castillo (SEA - SP) 27 +21
7 Corbin Burnes (FA - SP) FA 19 +12
8 George Kirby (SEA - SP) 31 +23
9 Tyler Glasnow (LAD - SP) 38 +29
10 Yoshinobu Yamamoto (LAD - SP) 42 +32
11 Aaron Nola (PHI - SP) 55 +44
15 Blake Snell (LAD - SP) 65 +50
17 Zac Gallen (ARI - SP) 41 +24
25 Shane Bieber (FA - SP) FA 142 +117
27 Edwin Diaz (NYM - RP) 45 +18
30 Tarik Skubal (DET - SP) 50 +20
32 Emmanuel Clase (CLE - RP) 66 +34
41 Framber Valdez (HOU - SP) 58 +17
44 Camilo Doval (SF - RP) 69 +25
45 Raisel Iglesias (ATL - RP) 68 +23
52 Gerrit Cole (NYY - SP) 257 +205
53 Pete Fairbanks (TB - RP) 115 +62
58 David Bednar (PIT - RP) 99 +41
59 Andres Munoz (SEA - RP) 89 +30
63 Alexis Diaz (CIN - RP) 101 +38
65 Evan Phillips (LAD - RP) 90 +25
67 Kyle Schwarber (PHI - LF,DH) 86 +19
68 Jhoan Duran (MIN - RP) 133 +65
69 Ryan Helsley (STL - RP) 104 +35
72 Cole Ragans (KC - SP,RP) 88 +16
81 Clay Holmes (FA - RP) FA 118 +37
84 Shota Imanaga (CHC - SP) 159 +75
85 Kenley Jansen (FA - RP) FA 191 +106
86 Tanner Scott (FA - RP) FA 134 +48
88 Dansby Swanson (CHC - SS) 119 +31
89 Hunter Greene (CIN - SP) 135 +46
90 Craig Kimbrel (FA - RP) FA 156 +66
92 Adbert Alzolay (FA - RP) FA 155 +63
98 Spencer Steer (CIN - 1B,2B,3B,LF) 110 +12
111 Michael King (SD - SP,RP) 129 +18
112 Jose Alvarado (PHI - RP) 202 +90
117 Yu Darvish (SD - SP) 197 +80
118 Jordan Montgomery (ARI - SP) 172 +54
119 Robert Suarez (SD - RP) 211 +92
122 Carlos Rodon (NYY - SP) 144 +22
125 Carlos Estevez (FA - RP) FA 226 +101
130 A.J. Puk (ARI - RP,SP) 258 +128
135 Jonathan India (KC - 2B,DH) 203 +68
136 Ezequiel Tovar (COL - SS) 182 +46
143 Jack Suwinski (PIT - LF,CF,RF) 247 +104
145 Walker Buehler (FA - SP) FA 174 +29
147 Robert Stephenson (LAA - RP) 383 +236
152 Rhys Hoskins (MIL - 1B,DH) 189 +37
153 Jordan Romano (FA - RP) FA 187 +34
154 Alex Lange (DET - RP) 239 +85
158 Carlos Correa (MIN - SS) 204 +46
159 Victor Scott (STL - CF) 333 +174
164 Nathan Eovaldi (FA - SP) FA 177 +13
165 Nathaniel Lowe (TEX - 1B) 230 +65
175 Gavin Stone (LAD - SP) 278 +103
176 Jose Leclerc (FA - RP) FA 193 +17
179 Kyle Finnegan (FA - RP) FA 275 +96
180 Jackson Holliday (BAL - 2B,SS) 232 +52
185 Ryan Mountcastle (BAL - 1B,DH) 199 +14
188 Garrett Crochet (CWS - SP,RP) 350 +162
189 Eury Perez (MIA - SP) 238 +49
190 Andrew Vaughn (CWS - 1B,DH) 209 +19
192 Bryan Woo (SEA - SP) 220 +28
193 Kevin Ginkel (ARI - RP) 293 +100
195 Yimi Garcia (FA - RP) FA 411 +216
196 Mason Miller (ATH - RP,SP) 229 +33
197 Michael Kopech (LAD - RP,SP) 316 +119
204 J.D. Martinez (FA - LF,DH) FA 223 +19
206 Zach Neto (LAA - SS) 255 +49
211 Matt Chapman (SF - 3B) 234 +23
215 Jake Fraley (CIN - LF,RF,DH) 277 +62
219 Ryan McMahon (COL - 2B,3B) 235 +16
220 Eduardo Rodriguez (ARI - SP) 270 +50
221 Trevor Megill (MIL - RP) 366 +145
222 Colt Keith (DET - 2B,3B,DH) 253 +31
223 Josh Bell (FA - 1B,DH) FA 260 +37
224 Jack Flaherty (FA - SP) FA 354 +130
225 Hunter Harvey (KC - RP) 271 +46
226 Will Smith (FA - RP) FA 274 +48
227 Yuki Matsui (SD - RP) 315 +88
228 David Robertson (FA - RP) FA 365 +137
229 Luis Severino (FA - SP) FA 280 +51
230 Jose Abreu (FA - 1B) FA 269 +39
238 Louie Varland (MIN - SP,RP) 264 +26
251 TJ Friedl (CIN - LF,CF) 325 +74
252 Abner Uribe (MIL - RP) 368 +116
256 James McArthur (KC - RP) 384 +128
257 Justin Lawrence (COL - RP) 380 +123
260 Brendan Rodgers (FA - 2B) FA 294 +34
264 Ryan Pressly (HOU - RP) 346 +82
269 Aroldis Chapman (FA - RP) FA 372 +103
270 Tommy Edman (LAD - 2B,SS,CF,RF) 296 +26
274 Luis Garcia (WSH - 2B) 388 +114
275 Jason Adam (SD - RP) 328 +53
276 Taj Bradley (TB - SP) 309 +33
281 Griffin Jax (MIN - RP) 307 +26
283 Joel Payamps (MIL - RP) 323 +40
287 Devin Williams (MIL - RP) 373 +86
292 Alek Thomas (ARI - CF) 344 +52
294 Yoan Moncada (FA - 3B) FA 331 +37
296 Andrew Benintendi (CWS - LF) 311 +15
300 Javier Baez (DET - SS) 378 +78