In the high-stakes world of fantasy baseball, every draft pick counts, and choosing between players with similar average draft positions (ADP) can make or break your season. Welcome to our expert series, where we delve deep into the stats, performance trends, and potential of closely ranked players to guide you through these tough decisions. Leveraging insights and the Who Should I Draft tool from FantasyPros, we compare two or three players at a time, dissecting their strengths, weaknesses, and overall fantasy value to determine who deserves a spot on your roster.
Whether you’re torn between promising rookies, seasoned veterans, or players coming off a breakout year, our detailed analysis will empower you with the knowledge to draft with confidence. Stay ahead of the slurve and dominate your league by making informed choices when it matters most.
Who Should I Draft? Salvador Perez vs. Sean Murphy?
Salvador Perez (C,1B,DH – KC): ECR 133.0
Salvador Perez remained a staple of the Kansas City Royals lineup in 2023, playing in 140 games and racking up 580 plate appearances. He hit .254 with a miserable .292 OBP and .422 SLG. He hit 23 home runs for the second year in a row and drove in 80. His projections for 2024 suggest more of the same for the 33-year-old. Perez is a catcher who isn’t going to drag down your batting average and give you 20+ homers. That is a rare bird; at his ADP of 133, he isn’t a bad value in 2024.
Sean Murphy (C – ATL): ECR 137.5
Sean Murphy’s first year in Atlant went swimmingly. He popped 21 home runs while driving in 68 and scoring 65 runs. Murphy’s strengths are his stellar OBP (.365) and walk rate (11.2%). His superb fielding skills will keep him in the lineup, even with Travis d’Arnaud on the roster, and he should get around 470 plate appearances. Fantasy managers can expect 20 homers and 60/60 in runs and RBIs while not being a liability to the team’s batting average. His current ADP is 137, a decent value for a catcher with his skillset and outstanding surrounding cast.
And the winner is…
According to the FantasyPros Who Should I Draft? tool, 69% of experts would draft Salvador Perez.
More Who Should I Draft?
- Bo Bichette vs. Gunnar Henderson
- Corey Seager vs. Francisco Lindor
- Elly De La Cruz vs. Royce Lewis
- Alex Bregman vs. Nolan Arenado
Check out all of our 2024 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit articles, tools, and more
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio