We’ve gone over a few different types of leagues in our preseason primers. We’ll continue comparing separate formats as we continue our ore-draft coverage at FantasyPros.
Up next is a comparison of two formats that are among the most popular for fantasy baseball players: roto and head-to-head (H2H).
The two are similar in many regards, but being aware of some key differences can give managers an edge over their opponents. Here, we will be diving into some of those key differences.
2024 Fantasy Baseball: Roto vs. H2H Primer
Timeframe
Arguably the biggest difference between the two types of leagues comes down to the timeframe. In a classic roto league, players’ stats accumulate throughout the season and the winner is deemed based on who has the best relative stats at the end of the year. For instance, in a 12-team league the team with the most home runs and third-most runs batted in would get 12 and nine points, respectively. Meanwhile, H2H leagues are typically weekly matchups against one other opponent.
Because of this difference, it’s much harder to ignore short-term noise in H2H leagues. If a player is going through a slump, you might consider sitting him in a H2H league where three or four bad games can really mess up your week. But if you’re in a roto league that is based on year-long stats, a few-game slump isn’t going to kill you in the long run.
A Numbers Game
Most of what roto vs, H2H comes down to is sample size. In weekly H2H leagues, your best hitters are going to face tough pitchers and go through slumps while your pitchers might get two starts and have two blowups . Therefore, that 0-16 rut your all-star outfielder is in is more likely to weigh on your results in a weekly league than in a year-long roto league.
Because volatile players can cause managers headaches, it’s often more favorable to draft more consistent players in H2H leagues than in roto leagues. Power hitters like Kyle Schwarber (OF,DH – PHI), who are particularly susceptible to boom and bust periods, are less attractive in H2H leagues. If he goes on to hit 45 home runs, it doesn’t matter when he hit them in a roto league, the numbers add up throughout the season. But in a H2H league, if 20 of those 45 home runs come in the final month of the season, that leaves a big power gap in your lineup for the first five months of the season.
The Approach
We’ve talked about punting earlier in our primer series and how it’s achievable in category leagues. I prefer to punt the stolen bases or go with the reliever-heavy strategy to lock up three categories in pitching each week and build a strong offense that can consistently win at least three categories.
But in roto leagues, it’s nearly impossible to punt and expect to win. If you finish in the middle of the pack in a category in a roto league, you’d essentially have to come in first or second in every other category to win.
In-Season Advice
Trading – and being active on the waiver wire for that matter – is huge in both leagues, but each has its own considerations. In roto leagues, I prefer to trade for stats that I am lagging in and be more willing to give up stats I’m set on. For instance, if I’m in first place in saves by a good margin but I’m near the bottom in stolen bases, I’d most likely trying to find a trading partner that has speedy guys and trade away my closers.
In comparison to a H2H league, I’m less likely to take a needs-based approach and take a more holistic approach. I still want to play to my strengths but because stats reset after every week, I’d be more hesitant to trade away my best power hitter unless I’m winning homeruns by a huge margin each week. As such, I find myself targeting “buy-low” players who can provide a nice boost across several categories.
Which Is Supreme?
I’ve played both leagues and there are pros and cons to each. I believe roto leagues awards the best manager with the most well-rounded team while H2H leagues involve much more luck. Not only are your players prone to slumps that can affect weekly matchups, but you’re also at the mercy of how your opponents’ players perform. Your guys can go on a tear one week and put up great numbers, but if your opponent has a better week, none of that really matters.
That said, I like two aspects of H2H leagues: the competition and keeping teams involved. I think H2H leagues do a much better job of keeping players active. The thought of managing a team for a 162-game season can be daunting, especially for new members. But if you break it down into weeks, H2H can seem much more manageable. And if you do have a bad week, the best part is that you have a clean slate to work with next week. These are both mental factors that I think are often overlooked in H2H leagues.
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio