Fantasy Baseball Draft Prospects: Colt Keith, Tyler Black, Curtis Mead, Coby Mayo (2024)

The new baseball season is nearly upon us! With new beginnings come new hopes and dreams. And what produces more hope and excitement than the stars of tomorrow? That’s right, I’m talking about prospects!

Top Prospect Rankings By Position: OF | 1B | SS | 2B
2024 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit
Fantasy Baseball Draft Rankings
Fantasy Baseball Projections

Prospects. The dream is they’ll all turn into superstars. While we know this isn’t true for most, the select few that do, make them very exciting to discuss. There are a handful that could break out in a big way at third base this year, so let’s get right to it.

Now, this being a fantasy sports site, we need to turn our focus to how these players can impact your fantasy squads. This piece will highlight which young studs at third base will help your team now. In other words, these next select few are the ones you should target in redraft leagues. They hold value in dynasty leagues as well, but that’s a whole other conversation for another time.

Third base has plenty of question marks this season after the top player on this list. They are all extremely talented but it’ll just come down to how much playing time they receive. Most likely all but the first player listed will start the year in the minors. However, a hot start or early injury could see any of these prospects be called up before the calendar flips to May.

Fantasy Baseball Prospects: Third Base

Colt Keith (2B, 3B – DET) | ADP: 423

Colt Keith was the Tigers’ best-hitting prospect last year. He amassed 27 dingers and 101 RBIs across 577 plate appearances in the upper minors. He finished the season with a batting average above .300 and plays both second and third base. He also produced a K-rate under 20% while earning a free pass nearly 12% of the time in triple-A. His main competition for playing time at the moment is Matt Vierling and Zach McKinstry. If Jack Flaherty and Kenta Maeda can have solid years in Detroit, the Tigers could make some noise this year in the AL Central. Keith makes them better on all fronts. If they’re serious about winning this year he could be up sooner than later.

Tyler Black (2B, 3B – MIL) | ADP: 428

We’ve seen Milwaukee start rookies on Opening Day before and Tyler Black could be next in line. The Brewers’ farm system is teeming with promising bats and their future third baseman is one of the most impressive. He mashed his way through the minors, finishing with a 144 wRC+ last year. He has a very patient eye at the dish, resulting in more walks than strikeouts (15.6 BB%, 13.3 K%). He is also lightning quick on the base paths and scores at will, reaching home 105 times while stealing 55 bases across both Double-A and Triple-A in 2023.

The lefty-swinging 23-year-old can hit for power as well. Black launched 18 homers, 12 triples and 25 doubles as he filled up the stat sheet on a nightly basis last year. The only players currently standing in his way are Andruw Monasterio and Jake Bauers. I love the former first-rounder late in drafts.

Curtis Mead (3B – TB) | ADP: 494

Curtis Mead earns an honorable mention because of his ability to make consistent contact. His main issue for fantasy purposes is he doesn’t offer much in either the power or speed departments. He likely won’t see regular playing time in Tampa. He’s worth a dart throw in extremely deep leagues but I have a hard time seeing him reach double-digit homers or steals. He likely won’t play enough to eclipse 45 RBIs or runs scored.

Coby Mayo (1B, 3B – TB) | ADP: 533

Coby Mayo is a 6-foot-5, 230-pound thumper who totaled 29 homers and 99 RBIs between Double-A and Triple-A last year. He also exhibits a great eye at the plate, resulting in a 15% walk rate. His wRC+ has been impressive since becoming a professional three years ago. If the Orioles suffer an injury early in the season, Mayo could be the first man up.