PREMIUM

WR vs. CB Matchups & Advice: Week 5 (2022 Fantasy Football)

Four weeks into the 2022 season, the biggest “League-wide” theme has been the drop in offensive performance. As we noted last week, many believe this is due to the increase in the 2-high shell looks defenses are showing. Whether this is causal or not is still being widely debated within the analytics circles. However, we need to remember coaches and OCs are human. And it’s VERY likely that they are seeing the same thing and making adjustments in the perpetual game of cat-and-mouse that is football strategy.

Here is what I mean by this:

Let’s assume that defenses have adjusted from the “post-Legion-of-Boom era,” with their single high, “Saben-Rip/Liz Match” type defenses, to using more 2-high safety looks
Let’s also assume THOSE DCs are doing this to limit explosive passing plays (i.e., putting a roof over the coverage and keeping everything in front of them)
If this is the case, we need to remember EVERYTHING in football strategy is a zero-sum game. Meaning if you do x instead of z, there will be pros and cons along with the decision
By using more 2-High shells, that means there can only be 7 or fewer players in the box

Now you astute football fans likely think that offenses will start to run more, and likely more effectively as well, to combat the 2-high look/take advantage of a lighter box. And you’d be absolutely correct. As Dan Pizzuta of Sharp Football Analysis noted:

Here is what I mean by this:

Let’s assume that defenses have adjusted from the “post-Legion-of-Boom era,” with their single high, “Saben-Rip/Liz Match” type defenses, to using more 2-high safety looks
Let’s also assume THOSE DCs are doing this to limit explosive passing plays (i.e., putting a roof over the coverage and keeping everything in front of them)
If this is the case, we need to remember EVERYTHING in football strategy is a zero-sum game. Meaning if you do x instead of z, there will be pros and cons along with the decision
By using more 2-High shells, that means there can only be 7 or fewer players in the box

“This also blends with the overall trend of passing efficiency being down across the league from prior years, as defenses are doing better at stopping the big play. Passing efficiency through four weeks is at its lowest over the past 10 years. Meanwhile, rushing efficiency is at its highest. Rushing still brings negative EPA, but we currently have the smallest gap between passing and rushing that we’ve seen in a while – and for this, scrambles are considered dropbacks.”

The chart he was citing, thanks to Sharp Football, is included below:

WEEK	EPA/PLAY	EPA/DRIVE	EPA/DB	EPA/RUSH
1	-0.01	-0.07	0.01	-0.07
2	0.00	0.00	0.03	-0.03
3	-0.03	-0.15	0.01	-0.05
4	0.00	-0.02	0.02	0.00

What all this means to us and this piece is: Not only are we working through an overall offensive downturn while trying to find WR value, but we are doing it while getting the “short end of the stick.” This may mean more RBs in the flex spot moving forward, etc., but that’s a story for another day.

Nonetheless, we need to start 2-3 WRs, and we will do our best in this environment to help you through those decisions.

Week 4 Results: 3-2

We ended positively last week, yet we failed for all intents and purposes. Our model absolutely loved Richie James, and he could not have let us down more, ending the day in the rare negative territory.

Name	FP Selection	Projected	Actual	Net
Richie James Jr.	START	10.7	-.1	-10.8 (L)
Romeo Doubs	START	12	13.7	+1.7 (W)
Drake London	START	13.1	3.7	-9.4 (L)
Mack Hollins	SIT	11.5	6.3	+5.2 (W)
Christian Kirk	SIT	14.2	8.3	+5.9 (W)

Season Scorecard

Season Record: 20-12
Total Net Points: 65.9
Net Points/Selection: +2.1

*All stats based on Yahoo Fantasy Football 1/2 PPR

Week 5 WR vs. CB Model Scorecard

		Raw Numbers				Weekly Rank
	Snaps	Wt.ed Net pprr	40 Adv.	HT Adv.	nPFFwted Total	Wt.ed Net pprr	40 Adv.	HT Adv.	nPFFwted Total	Avg. Rk.
Amon-Ra St. Brown	49.2	24.4	0.00	3.54	20.1	7	33	18	2	15
Stefon Diggs	56.5	24.1	0.13	0.84	8.7	8	6	55	16	21
Tee Higgins	53.5	20.3	0.00	3.79	5.6	15	33	15	28	23
Jerry Jeudy	51.5	18.5	0.01	2.98	13.2	24	31	31	8	24
Justin Jefferson	60.9	24.1	0.03	1.67	5.8	9	16	43	27	24
D.K. Metcalf	53.5	16.9	0.03	2.95	9.5	33	20	33	12	25
Amari Cooper	54.9	21.3	0.02	2.03	6.4	11	25	39	24	25
A.J. Brown	57.1	22.1	0.01	0.83	14.3	10	30	56	5	25
DeVante Parker	54.2	16.9	0.03	1.95	9.0	32	18	40	14	26
Drake London	53.9	21.3	0.00	3.53	1.3	12	33	19	50	29
Terry McLaurin	78.1	24.9	0.19	1.00	0.7	6	2	52	56	29
Mike Evans	55.5	26.5	-0.05	5.09	4.5	5	77	2	34	30
D.J. Chark Jr.	50.9	13.6	0.13	5.48	0.4	54	5	1	59	30
Cody Hollister	40.1	13.0	0.00	4.07	8.7	61	33	11	15	30
Cooper Kupp	62.7	26.7	-0.10	3.10	17.4	4	89	27	3	31
Adam Thielen	59.3	17.8	0.00	2.72	5.3	29	33	35	30	32
Josh Reynolds	49.7	17.5	-0.03	4.48	7.3	30	75	6	18	32
Zay Jones	49.2	16.0	0.02	3.04	4.5	38	26	30	35	32
DeVonta Smith	62.2	18.8	0.00	-0.25	13.4	21	33	69	7	33
Romeo Doubs	47.0	13.7	0.00	1.86	14.4	53	33	41	4	33
Nelson Agholor	48.2	18.6	0.06	-0.81	6.2	23	9	75	25	33
Tyreek Hill	71.0	33.4	0.00	-0.83	6.2	2	33	76	26	34
Mike Williams	54.5	16.9	0.00	3.21	2.5	34	33	25	45	34
Curtis Samuel	46.1	15.1	0.21	0.00	4.8	42	1	66	32	35
Greg Dortch	45.3	18.6	0.00	-2.43	24.3	22	33	88	1	36
Chris Olave	54.1	18.3	0.03	-0.87	6.8	26	22	77	19	36
Julio Jones	41.6	13.2	0.03	3.14	2.0	60	14	26	47	37
Jaylen Waddle	78.1	35.3	0.00	-2.37	4.9	1	33	86	31	38
Corey Davis	47.1	14.9	0.00	2.73	3.2	45	33	34	39	38
Allen Lazard	48.7	14.1	-0.07	4.83	9.3	50	86	4	13	38
Tyler Boyd	58.5	18.2	-0.01	1.12	13.4	27	73	48	6	39
Noah Brown	34.0	13.2	0.00	2.60	3.4	59	33	36	37	41
Marquez Valdes-Scantling	47.6	11.0	0.05	4.83	-3.2	69	11	3	82	41
Equanimeous St. Brown	41.2	9.6	0.01	4.37	1.0	77	29	7	54	42
Courtland Sutton	58.0	19.1	-0.06	3.40	2.6	19	84	21	44	42
Marquise Brown	60.7	21.3	0.00	-2.38	3.9	13	33	87	36	42
Devin Duvernay	37.2	13.8	0.01	0.46	5.6	52	28	63	29	43
K.J. Osborn	49.4	14.6	0.00	-0.54	6.5	47	33	71	23	44
George Pickens	55.0	10.2	0.03	3.28	0.4	73	21	22	58	44
Gabriel Davis	39.4	8.6	0.04	3.92	-1.0	82	12	12	69	44
Nico Collins	43.2	12.0	0.00	3.91	-0.3	65	33	13	65	44
Ja’Marr Chase	61.7	18.4	0.00	-0.20	1.2	25	33	68	51	44
Isaiah McKenzie	28.0	10.2	0.19	-2.34	8.6	72	3	85	17	44
Chase Claypool	51.2	7.9	0.07	4.35	-2.0	84	8	9	78	45
Garrett Wilson	40.5	14.1	0.04	0.83	0.2	49	13	57	61	45
Donovan Peoples-Jones	53.7	15.2	-0.01	3.09	2.7	41	69	28	43	45
CeeDee Lamb	73.5	28.8	-0.06	2.51	0.0	3	81	37	62	46
Christian Kirk	53.6	19.3	0.00	0.65	-1.6	18	32	60	73	46
Robbie Anderson	57.0	15.0	0.00	3.66	-5.8	44	33	16	90	46
Randall Cobb	36.9	8.8	0.01	-0.10	12.8	80	27	67	9	46
Michael Pittman Jr.	59.6	15.6	-0.06	4.29	0.8	40	82	10	55	47
Rashod Bateman	48.4	16.3	0.00	1.33	-1.5	37	33	46	72	47
Brandin Cooks	53.9	16.6	0.02	-1.36	1.2	35	24	80	52	48
KhaDarel Hodge	36.8	16.0	0.00	-1.82	3.2	39	33	81	38	48
Darnell Mooney	60.8	14.7	0.15	-1.32	-0.2	46	4	79	63	48
Lil’Jordan Humphrey	34.8	8.6	-0.24	4.76	10.0	81	95	5	11	48
Robert Woods	56.6	19.8	-0.06	-1.10	6.7	17	79	78	21	49
Tyler Lockett	56.1	18.8	-0.01	-2.00	6.7	20	70	83	22	49
Chris Godwin	54.9	18.1	0.00	1.74	-9.7	28	33	42	95	50
Marvin Jones Jr.	58.0	13.0	0.00	2.95	-1.3	62	33	32	71	50
Chris Moore	30.9	7.5	-0.02	3.23	6.7	86	74	24	20	51
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine	39.7	9.4	0.00	0.98	3.1	79	33	54	40	52
Bennett Skowronek	55.7	12.2	0.00	3.06	-2.6	64	33	29	81	52
Mack Hollins	36.5	10.5	-0.04	3.47	2.2	71	76	20	46	53
Davante Adams	57.4	20.6	-0.10	0.42	1.8	14	88	64	48	54
Josh Palmer	35.3	9.4	0.00	1.32	0.6	78	33	47	57	54
Deebo Samuel	52.9	17.4	-0.06	0.72	1.6	31	80	59	49	55
Jauan Jennings	40.0	10.7	-0.07	3.84	1.2	70	87	14	53	56
Michael Gallup	49.6	20.0	-0.05	0.79	-1.7	16	78	58	74	57
Jarvis Landry	49.5	16.3	-0.29	-2.46	12.7	36	96	90	10	58
Olamide Zaccheaus	39.0	15.1	0.00	-3.57	-0.3	43	33	93	66	59
Mecole Hardman	50.4	12.6	0.03	-0.58	-4.1	63	15	72	85	59
DeAndre Carter	40.1	11.6	0.00	-4.58	2.7	66	33	96	42	59
Quez Watkins	46.3	9.9	0.03	0.61	-4.1	76	17	61	84	60
Dyami Brown	35.5	7.8	0.00	1.00	-0.6	85	33	52	68	60
Darius Slayton	45.1	5.5	0.03	1.46	-3.8	93	19	44	83	60
D.J. Moore	56.3	13.2	0.00	-0.60	-1.8	58	33	73	76	60
Trent Sherfield	32.3	7.0	0.00	1.45	-2.2	87	33	45	80	61
Dante Pettis	46.5	10.2	0.00	0.35	-2.0	74	33	65	79	63
Elijah Moore	45.1	11.2	0.00	-2.17	-0.4	68	33	84	67	63
Parris Campbell	46.6	6.9	0.02	1.00	-5.6	89	23	51	89	63
Brandon Aiyuk	54.6	14.4	-0.06	0.52	0.2	48	83	62	60	63
Allen Robinson II	54.4	11.5	-0.10	3.26	-1.8	67	90	23	75	64
JuJu Smith-Schuster	49.7	13.5	0.00	1.08	-6.6	55	68	49	91	66
Diontae Johnson	58.5	13.3	-0.12	-1.97	4.7	57	91	82	33	66
Marquez Callaway	48.8	13.4	-0.18	-0.60	2.9	56	94	74	41	66
David Bell	25.9	5.6	-0.01	3.57	-4.7	92	71	17	86	67
Marquise Goodwin	29.7	5.0	0.06	-3.12	-1.1	94	10	92	70	67
Richie James Jr.	42.7	10.2	0.08	-4.48	-6.8	75	7	94	92	67
K.J. Hamler	32.1	6.6	0.00	-2.46	-0.2	90	33	89	64	69
David Sills	31.2	4.4	-0.07	4.35	-5.5	96	85	8	88	69
Shi Smith	33.4	6.9	0.00	-0.46	-6.8	88	33	70	93	71
Alec Pierce	19.1	4.5	-0.01	2.33	-5.4	95	72	38	87	73
Demarcus Robinson	40.7	8.0	-0.15	1.00	-1.9	83	92	50	77	76
Rondale Moore	32.4	6.3	0.00	-4.49	-8.4	91	33	95	94	78
Hunter Renfrow	49.8	14.0	-0.17	-2.85	-13.1	51	93	91	96	83

*Again, thanks to our friends at PFF for the data
**To standardize all variables we are tracking (and make it easier to read), we included a RANK Display, respective of each data point to the right AND sorted by the average rank across variables.

Legend

Snaps: estimated total dropback snaps a WR will play in the coming matchup
Wt.ed Net PPRR: “Weighted Net Fantasy Points/Route Run.” Simply this is the net value of a WR’s PPRR average vs. the DB’s PPRR given up, weighted according to the DB each WR is expected to play.

Wt.ed Net PPRR Example:

Say Davante Adams averages 2.0 points/route run

DB1 (expected to face 50% of snaps) gives up 3.0 points/route run
DB2 (expected to face 30% of snaps) gives up 4.0 points/route run
DB3 (expected to face 20% of snaps) gives up 1.0 points/route run

This first model would predict Adams to produce 2.45 points/route run (Adams 2.0 vs. aggregate defenders averages weighted to 2.9)

*40 Adv: “40 Yard Dash Advantage” (weighted difference between WR 40 time and DBs)
*HT Adv: “Height Advantage” (same as above, but with height)
nPFFwted Total: “Net PFF weighted Total Advantage.” Our core model, similar to the Wt.ed Net PPRR above, it compares the PFF grade between WR and likely DB, weighted by expected snaps he’ll see each respective DB

*Not all WRs and DBs have 40 times and/or height measurements. When this occurs with ONE party, the model ignores the other (i.e., you need a WR and DB with a 40 time for this data point to populate)

Bonus Chart

Most frequently targeted CBs (Rookies Highlighted in yellow)

Although not officially worked into our model, we do like to use the info above (thanks again to PFF) to support some of our decisions.

WR Matchups to Target in Week 5

*For the matchup sections below, we refrain from “obvious recommendations” and/or players you are starting no matter what (and the opposite for players recommended to sit)

Cody Hollister (WR – TEN)

“Deep Pick Alert.” Hollister surprised us as much as you. However, for non-clear-starters, he comes in as the highest-rated WR at 15. This is mainly fueled by a physical advantage. He is expected to see the majority of snaps vs. Kendall Fuller, who he has a whopping 5-inch advantage on (76 vs. 71 inches). To be fair, we’re counting on this to be an endzone/touchdown-dependent type play for the veteran, “no name” WR.

Adam Thielen (WR – MIN)

This may push the boundary for a “non-obvious starter” after the vet has put together back-to-back double-digit outings in a row (in Jefferson’s shadow). Nonetheless, we really like Thielen this week and are happy to continue to take the “1B to Jefferson discount” we’re still getting with him. He comes in as our 17th-best matchup and will face the majority of snaps vs. Bears CB Kindle Vildor and his 54.3 PFF grade.

Josh Reynolds (WR – DET)

Reynolds has quietly put together a stellar WR season, especially if you exclude week 1. He is seemingly fitting into the void our model keeps picking up for DJ Chark, and we finally have a week that our model is calling for him. Reynolds comes in with a great height advantage and a good grade advantage, assuming he will see Jonathan Jones (42%) and Jalen Mills (37%) on expected pass snaps.

Others to consider bumping up this week:

Zay Jones
Mike Williams

WR Matchups to Avoid in Week 5

Hunter Renfrow (WR – LV)

Admittedly, we are most excited to handle this write-up, knowing Renfrow is the top WR free agent pickup in about 29% of leagues this week and may seem enticing coming back from injury. However, Renfrow is our absolute worst matchup ranking for the week. He just about “checks all boxes” in the opposite direction. Clearly, we are not going to bring up any physical matchup disadvantages, as Renfrow has played with that handicap his whole career, but his comparative numbers are just as bad. Being the slot WR that he is, it’s looking like he will spend the day putting up his measly 55 PFF grade vs. L’Jarius Sneed‘s 82.9.

Davante Adams (WR – LV)

Yes, we are basically shorting the Raiders’ offense here. Beyond the mismatch Renfrow will have with Sneed, this is a rare game Adams pops up here. This is especially considering the Raiders have made it a point to feed him the ball after a couple of weeks of failing to do so. Either way, Adams comes in with a bad matchup in height and speed and one of the lower net yards per route run, at least for him (coming in at 48th on the week). With how much the Raiders move Adams around, he doesn’t really have a true “Shadow” in this game and will likely see three different defenders somewhat equally, but they all have lower NYPRRs than Adams’ 1.75 (Jaylen Watson with 1.12, Rashad Fenton at 1.15 and Sneed at 1.19).

Others to consider sitting:

Tyler Lockett
Michael Pittman

After a clunker last week, we’re looking to crush week 5. Best of luck to you all.

If you want to dive deeper into fantasy football, be sure to check out our award-winning slate of Fantasy Football Tools as you navigate your season. From our Start/Sit Assistant – which provides your optimal lineup based on accurate consensus projections – to our Waiver Wire Assistant – which allows you to quickly see which available players will improve your team and by how much – we’ve got you covered this fantasy football season.

Subscribe to Continue

Unlock powerful tools, features, and content for all sports. Dominate for as low as $3.99/mo.

Upgrade To Premium

DFS Football NFL Premium

About Author

Ryan Newman

Ryan Newman is a featured writer at FantasyPros, providing unique insights and in-depth analysis.

Week 4 Results: 3-2

Season Scorecard

Week 5 WR vs. CB Model Scorecard

Legend

Bonus Chart

WR Matchups to Target in Week 5

WR Matchups to Avoid in Week 5

More Articles

Fantasy Football Week 16 Start/Sit Advice: 12 Sleepers & Duds (2025)

Chalkboard Fantasy Sports: Week 16 TNF Picks

Fantasy Football Start/Sit Advice: Safe & Risky Picks (Week 16)

6 Fantasy Football Lineup Landmines: Start/Sit Advice (Week 16)

Fantasy Football NFL Air Yards Analysis & Takeaways (Week 16)

NFL DFS Lineup Advice: Picks & Predictions (Week 16)

The Primer: Week 16 Edition (2025 Fantasy Football)

Fantasy Football Start/Sit Lineup Advice: Tight Ends (Week 16)

Fantasy Football Start/Sit Lineup Advice: Wide Receivers (Week 16)

Fantasy Football Start/Sit Lineup Advice: Running Backs (Week 16)

About Author