Skip to main content

Fantasy Baseball Trade Value Chart (Week 9)

Fantasy Baseball Trade Value Chart (Week 9)

The old adage with trading in fantasy baseball is: “Make sure you get the best player in the deal.” It’s a simple concept but, other than with rare exceptions where each player thinks he or she is making out like a bandit, it’s not possible to make any deal workable for both sides if everyone holds to that maxim.

Personally, in anything deeper than 10-team leagues, I’ve never subscribed to the “get the best player at all costs” concept. There are plenty of times where you are not only forced but should strive to give up the best player in the deal. For example, if you’re looking at multiple weak spots in your lineup, adding solid depth to your roster at the expense of a better player is often the way to go. Perhaps you have several injured studs and are unable to make your roster work absent moving one of them to open a spot, even at the expense of downgrading a player in a vacuum.

The only principle to follow in trades is: “Make a deal that makes your team better.” Everything else is window dressing.

And to help you make the right choice in any trade, you should consult our rotisserie league trade chart below. Updated every week, the trade chart is an easy way to evaluate any trade to see if you’re getting a fair deal.

Import your team to My Playbook for season-long advice partner-arrow

Player Current Value Previous Value +/-
Mike Trout 67 70 -3
Christian Yelich 65 64 +1
Mookie Betts 63 63
Nolan Arenado 59 59
Alex Bregman 58 58
Javier Baez 57 58 -1
J.D. Martinez 57 57
Trevor Story 57 57
Francisco Lindor 57 57
Cody Bellinger 57 53 +4
Whit Merrifield 55 55
Ronald Acuna Jr. 55 55
Adalberto Mondesi 55 55
Trea Turner 54 54
Max Scherzer 54 58 -4
Justin Verlander 54 54
Blake Snell 53 52 +1
Chris Sale 52 52
Gerrit Cole 52 51 +1
Jacob deGrom 52 52
Manny Machado 52 53 -1
Freddie Freeman 52 53 -1
Paul Goldschmidt 51 53 -2
Charlie Blackmon 50 53 -3
Jose Ramirez 50 49 +1
Bryce Harper 48 48
Jose Altuve 43 52 -9
Rhys Hoskins 42 43 -1
Trevor Bauer 40 42 -2
Kris Bryant 40 37 +3
Zack Greinke 39 39
Stephen Strasburg 39 39
Clayton Kershaw 39 39
Gary Sanchez 39 39
Anthony Rizzo 39 37 +2
Starling Marte 36 36
Khris Davis 36 40 -4
Anthony Rendon 36 38 -2
Andrew Benintendi 36 40 -4
Joey Gallo 35 35
Patrick Corbin 34 28 +6
Aaron Nola 33 35 -2
Hyun-Jin Ryu 30 27 +3
Walker Buehler 29 28 +1
Carlos Carrasco 29 33 -4
Luis Castillo 29 31 -2
Noah Syndergaard 29 32 -3
Juan Soto 28 28
Xander Bogaerts 28 28
Tommy Pham 28 28
Eddie Rosario 27 23 +4
J.T. Realmuto 27 26 +1
Eugenio Suarez 25 25
Marcell Ozuna 25 22 +3
George Springer 25 37 -12
Victor Robles 24 21 +3
Jose Abreu 24 23 +1
James Paxton 24 21 +3
Matt Chapman 22 18 +4
Shane Bieber 21 21
Nelson Cruz 21 21
Ozzie Albies 21 21
Jose Berrios 21 21
Pete Alonso 20 18 +2
Jack Flaherty 20 19 +1
David Price 20 18 +2
Josh Bell 20 15 +5
Mitch Haniger 19 17 +2
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 19 22 -3
Kenley Jansen 19 18 +1
Mike Soroka 18 17 +1
Aroldis Chapman 18 18
Edwin Diaz 18 18
Yoan Moncada 17 17
Elvis Andrus 17 17
Yasmani Grandal 17 17
Willson Contreras 17 17
Austin Meadows 17 12 +5
Kirby Yates 17 17
Jonathan Villar 16 16
Michael Brantley 16 16
Giancarlo Stanton 15 15
Paul DeJong 15 15
German Marquez 15 17 -2
Roberto Osuna 15 15
Brad Hand 15 15
Josh Hader 15 14 +1
Charlie Morton 15 15
Mike Moustakas 15 15
Aaron Judge 15 15
Fernando Tatis Jr. 14 15 -1
Lorenzo Cain 14 16 -2
Felipe Vazquez 14 14
Caleb Smith 14 15 -1
Matthew Boyd 14 12 +2
Carlos Correa 13 23 -10
Nick Senzel 13 13
Michael Conforto 13 12 +1
Justin Turner 12 11 +1
Edwin Encarnacion 12 14 -2
Byron Buxton 12 12
Andrew McCutchen 12 12
Zack Wheeler 12 12
Blake Treinen 12 12
Chris Paddack 12 12
Matt Carpenter 11 12 -1
Yasiel Puig 11 10 +1
Jean Segura 10 9 +1
Madison Bumgarner 10 10
Gleyber Torres 10 8 +2
Masahiro Tanaka 9 7 +2
Tim Anderson 9 10 -1
Jordan Hicks 9 9
Franmil Reyes 9 9
Jorge Polanco 9 9
Max Muncy 9 8 +1
Raisel Iglesias 9 9
Mike Clevinger 9 8 +1
Joey Votto 8 10 -2
Luke Voit 8 5 +3
Tyler Glasnow 8 8
Brandon Woodruff 8 4 +4
Sean Doolittle 8 8
Rich Hill 8 8
Cole Hamels 8 8
Kyle Hendricks 8 8
Mike Minor 8 6 +2
Frankie Montas 8 8
Ken Giles 7 7
Austin Riley 7 4 +3
Domingo German 7 8 -1
Wil Myers 7 7
David Dahl 7 8 -1
Corey Seager 7 7
Matt Olson 7 6 +1
Nicholas Castellanos 7 4 +3
Domingo Santana 6 4 +2
Michael Chavis 6 3 +3
Rafael Devers 6 4 +2
Miles Mikolas 6 7 -1
Matt Strahm 6 6
Lucas Giolito 6 N/A +6
Stephen Piscotty 5 5
Max Fried 5 5
Ketel Marte 5 N/A +5
Gregory Polanco 5 4 +1
Hunter Dozier 5 5
Ryan Braun 5 5
Corey Kluber 5 5
Brad Peacock 5 5
Joe Musgrove 5 9 -4
Eloy Jimenez 5 4 +1
Aaron Hicks 5 5
Eric Hosmer 5 3 +2
Luis Severino 5 5
Eduardo Escobar 5 5
Buster Posey 5 9 -4
Yadier Molina 5 7 -2
Wilson Ramos 5 5
Scooter Gennett 4 3 +1
David Peralta 4 5 -1
Rougned Odor 4 6 -2
Chris Archer 4 9 -5
Robbie Ray 4 5 -1
Jose Quintana 4 4
Sonny Gray 4 4
Jake Odorizzi 4 2 +2
Jon Lester 4 4
Eduardo Rodriguez 4 4
Hector Neris 4 2 +2
Greg Holland 4 4
Craig Kimbrel 4 4
Dee Gordon 4 7 -3
Keston Hiura 4 4
Josh Donaldson 4 9 -5
Alex Colome 4 4
Wade Davis 3 7 -4
C.J. Cron 3 2 +1
Shohei Ohtani 3 3
Kenta Maeda 3 2 +1
Miguel Sano 3 N/A +3
Daniel Murphy 3 4 -1
Jonathan Schoop 3 2 +1
Nomar Mazara 3 3
Yu Darvish 3 4 -1
Jameson Taillon 3 3
Max Kepler 3 N/A +3
Carlos Santana 2 2
Sergio Romo 2 2
Yusei Kikuchi 2 2
Matt Barnes 2 2
Zach Eflin 2 3 -1
Shane Greene 2 2
Justin Smoak 2 N/A +2
Jurickson Profar 2 N/A +2
Martin Perez 2 N/A +2
Mallex Smith 2 2
Shin-Soo Choo 2 2
Tommy La Stella 2 N/A +2
Pedro Strop 2 N/A +2

 
The majority of pitchers who saw changes in their value did so simply because of tiering. Max Scherzer’s porous bullpen behind him and inability to tack on wins — and yes, they, like any other rotisserie category, need to be considered — moves him from his own mini-tier into one with the other big six. And Patrick Corbin’s continued excellence, along with Hyun-Jin Ryu’s total dominance, vaults them into the same trade value tier as Aaron Nola and Walker Buehler.

But it wasn’t all about tiering for pitchers. David Price’s and James Paxton’s outstanding returns from injury positively impact their value, as does Brandon Woodruff’s run of excellent starts and Lucas Giolito’s torrid run of late. But German Marquez’s struggles at home and Chris Archer’s inability to get settled in after his thumb injury drop both pitchers in value.

As for hitters, some notable injuries had large negative impacts for certain hitters, including Jose Altuve’s leg fatigue, George Springer’s hamstring strain, and Carlos Correa’s fractured rib. The Astros’ large division lead means they can, for the most part, wait out these injuries, but the same probably is not true for fantasy owners.

Finally, it is impossible to ignore the recent play of Josh Bell, Austin Meadows, or Pete Alonso. Bell ranks near the top of the league in every statcast metric and already has 17 homers and 51 RBI. He has been a steady riser over the last several weeks and should continue to move up. Meadows has four straight multi-hit efforts and five in his last six games and is batting an incredible .360 with the metrics to back it up. And no one other than Gary Sanchez hits the ball as consistently hard as Pete Alonso, who bounced back nicely from his recent slump and now has an impressive 19 home runs.  There is little reason to doubt any of the three.

Import your team to My Playbook for custom advice all season partner-arrow


SubscribeApple Podcasts | Google Play | SoundCloud | Stitcher | TuneIn

Dan Harris is a featured writer for FantasyPros. For more from Dan, check out his archive or follow him on Twitter @danharris80.

More Articles

Video: 11 Fantasy Baseball Draft Rankings Risers (2025)

Video: 11 Fantasy Baseball Draft Rankings Risers (2025)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 2 min read
Video: Fantasy Baseball MLB Free Agency Preview (2025)

Video: Fantasy Baseball MLB Free Agency Preview (2025)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 2 min read
10 Burning Questions: Jackson Jobe, Grayson Rodriguez, Ha-Seong Kim (Fantasy Baseball)

10 Burning Questions: Jackson Jobe, Grayson Rodriguez, Ha-Seong Kim (Fantasy Baseball)

fp-headshot by Corey Pieper | 4 min read
MLB DFS Picks & Player Prop Bets: Saturday (9/28)

MLB DFS Picks & Player Prop Bets: Saturday (9/28)

fp-headshot by Joel Bartilotta | 1 min read

About Author

Hide

Current Article

3 min read

Video: 11 Fantasy Baseball Draft Rankings Risers (2025)

Next Up - Video: 11 Fantasy Baseball Draft Rankings Risers (2025)

Next Article