Who Should I Draft?
Eli Manning or Tony Romo (2013)
Giants
CowboysExpert Picks
8%
92%
Expert Consensus Rank (ECR)
13
12
Best Rank
10
8
Worst Rank
16
14
Best
249.6
290.2
Worst
236.6
275.0
| Pass Yards | 4142 |
4769 |
| Pass TDs | 27 |
29.5 |
| Ints | 16 |
15.5 |
| Rush Yards | 24 |
48.5 |
| Tommy Rowan Juan Elway | “Manning will be solid, yet unspectacular again in 2013, but can't complain as he should be drafted as the first fantasy backup.” | “Romo gets little respect in fantasy circles, but I will be glad to grab him in he mid to late rounds while Ioad up on skill position players.” |
| Raju Byfield Win My Fantasy League | “A healthy Nicks is a major boost to Eli's fantasy value” | “Additions of Williams, Randle help solve depth issues, can keep going strong even if injuries at RB and WR strike” |
 Chet GreshamThe Fake Football | “If his WRs can stay healthy he could have a bounce back fantasy season.” | “I would have no problem grabbing Romo as my QB later in the draft. Always a top 10 fantasy QB when healthy.” |
| Staff Rankings FFLockerRoom | “Manning's receiving options have taken a hit at the tight end position this off-season. He still remains a solid high-end QB2 option in deeper leagues though.” | “Don't let Romo's new contract fool you. He is still no better than a low-end QB1 option in deeper leagues.” |
| Derek Lofland Fantasy Football Maniax | “Eli had a down year with 3,948 yards, 26 passing touchdowns and 15 interceptions. He was unplayable most weeks in the second half of the season; I look for him to rebound in 2013.” | “Romo had his usually impressive fantasy season with 4,903 yards passing, 28 passing touchdowns and 19 interceptions. He may not be able to win Week 17 games or earn playoff wins, but he is a great fantasy option. The Cowboys have added little offensive line help, so expect him to be under pressure again in 2013.” |
| Kyle Wachtel Forensic Fantasy | “Should settle in-between ’11 and ‘12” | “Love or hate him; he’s a solid QB1” |
| Kevin Roberts NFL Soup | “Eli is still too inconsistent for my liking, but he's still an elite option who you can get way later than you should be able to.” | “Does no one else see what a beast this guy is? If only his team could match his intensity all the time.” |
