Who Should I Draft?
Eli Manning or Michael Vick (2013)
Giants
EaglesExpert Picks
87%
13%
Expert Consensus Rank (ECR)
13
15
Best Rank
10
12
Worst Rank
16
25
Best
249.6
219.4
Worst
236.6
206.7
| Pass Yards | 4142 |
2788 |
| Pass TDs | 27 |
17.5 |
| Ints | 16 |
12.5 |
| Rush Yards | 24 |
555.5 |
| Tommy Rowan Juan Elway | “Manning will be solid, yet unspectacular again in 2013, but can't complain as he should be drafted as the first fantasy backup.” | “If he is named the starter for game #1 then he is a nice high risk, high reward player in Chip Kelly's offense.” |
| Raju Byfield Win My Fantasy League | “A healthy Nicks is a major boost to Eli's fantasy value” | “Impossible to rank Vick as anything less than a QB1 despite injury risk. Chip Kelly's offense could help this Eagle soar to new heights.” |
 Chet GreshamThe Fake Football | “If his WRs can stay healthy he could have a bounce back fantasy season.” | “He could be the backup come game one, but he still brings a ton of upside if he's starting. His ranking will rise if he starts.” |
| Staff Rankings FFLockerRoom | “Manning's receiving options have taken a hit at the tight end position this off-season. He still remains a solid high-end QB2 option in deeper leagues though.” | “Vick has a chance to be a key bounce-back player of the year. Still, he is no longer a spring chicken and can be relied on as nothing more than your second option at quarterback this fantasy season.” |
| Derek Lofland Fantasy Football Maniax | “Eli had a down year with 3,948 yards, 26 passing touchdowns and 15 interceptions. He was unplayable most weeks in the second half of the season; I look for him to rebound in 2013.” | “The one thing keeping Vick on the roster is that he has the skill set to run Chip Kelly's uptempo offense. If Kelly wants to stay in the league, he needs to go in another direction. Vick has never shown he can stay healthy, I doubt he will be able to stay healthy next year at the age of 33. The Eagles drafted QB Matt Barkley, so if Vick struggles out of the gate, he could be shown the bench early.” |
| Kyle Wachtel Forensic Fantasy | “Should settle in-between ’11 and ‘12” | “Front-runner for starting gig; potential ” |
| Kevin Roberts NFL Soup | “Eli is still too inconsistent for my liking, but he's still an elite option who you can get way later than you should be able to.” | “Is he even Chip Kelly's guy? And will it matter with his inability to take care of the ball or stay healthy? Nobody knows for sure.” |
| Sky Sperling Razzball | “http://football.razzball.com/michael-and-eagles-extend-lease-avoid-e-vick-tion” |
