Who Should I Draft?
Andre Johnson or Roddy White (2013)
Texans
FalconsExpert Picks
59%
41%
Expert Consensus Rank (ECR)
7
8
Best Rank
2
3
Worst Rank
15
20
Best
190.0
181.0
Worst
146.9
176.0
| Receptions | 95.7 |
94.3 |
| Rec Yards | 1333.7 |
1306.7 |
| Rec TDs | 6.3 |
8 |
| Neil Parker The Fake Football | “A top 10 WR in 4 of the past 5 years, but it would be nice to see a few more TDs. Tough to complain though, with the big reception and yard totals.” | “5 year averages of 96 catches, 1314 yards and 9 TDs. Impressive, but the supporting cast is better than ever now, so no reason to expect anything different.” |
| Coleman Kelly Sports Wunderkind | “Johnson seems ageless, but Father Time comes for all wide receivers sooner or later. I wouldn't bank on anything more than 2 years of top production.” | “Roddy White is hurtling towards the wide receiver production cliff at breakneck speed. It's hardly to endorse a 31 year old declining wide receiver.” |
| Jeff Brubach The Fake Football | “As with Roddy, another 3 top flight years are expected…just hope you get a couple solid years after that point. Can't argue with the present production one bit.” | “Getting older, but how can you argue with a 6 year avg of 94 rec and 1,296 yards? Roddy has at least another 3-4 top level years left, and is a proven stud commodity.” |
 Brandon FunstonYahoo! Sports | “Soon-to-be 32; just 6 TDs in his past 23 regular season games” | “Steady Roddy has been top 10 FAN WR for 5 straight seasons” |
| Derek Lofland Fantasy Football Maniax | “I was very unimpressed with Johnson's 7th overall ranking. He did finish with 112 receptions for 1,598 yards, but he had only four receiving touchdowns. There were too many games where he did not play like a WR1 for my liking.” | “White had another monster year with 92 receptions for 1351 yards and seven touchdowns, but he is 32 years old this year and Jones is taking over as the team's top wideout.” |
| Sean Morris Bruno Boys | “Was quietly very good down the stretch last season finishing WR5 over the last 8 weeks. He's about as consistent a fantasy scorer as they come, finishing top 10 at his position in every full season since 2007. He's getting old but the Texans will pass more this season as they look to rest Foster and take advantage of new weapon DeAndre Hopkins. Johnson isn't going to set the world on fire but he will put up reliably elite numbers with little or no risk.” | |
| Kevin Roberts NFL Soup | “AJ still has the goods, and Hopkins coming on could help with double teams.” | “White is aging like a fine wine. There's no reason to suspect any sudden drop off in production.” |
| Tommy Rowan Juan Elway | “A yardage and reception beast, but he STILL hasn't EVER reached double digit TDs.” | “Still playing at a high level and did his fair share of damage despite Julio Jones emergence.” |
| Staff Rankings FFLockerRoom | “Johnson was able to stay healthy in 2012 and in doing so produced his 4th seasons with at least 100-plus receptions as a Bounce Back player in 2012. Johnson should be viewed as a low-end No.1 Fantasy WR in PPR formats and a SOLID No.2 Fantasy WR in standard leagues worth drafting as early as late-3rd Round and into the 4th as a Top 15 Wide Receiver.” | “White recorded his 6th straight season with 80 receptions, his 3rd straight season with 90 receptions and his 5th season with at least 1,200 yards receiving (3rd season of 1,300 yards). Consider him a low-end No.1 Fantasy WR in all leagues worth drafting as early as Round 3.” |
| Chet Gresham The Fake Football | “Finished last season strong. Still one of the best in the biz.” | “He's as steady as they go. More upside in PPR with Jones taking some TDs away.” |
| Kyle Wachtel Forensic Fantasy | “Still padding a HOF career” | “Been a rock at this position for several years” |
| Nathan Miller Revelation Sports | “Julio hype has overshadowed the seasoned vet. Come to the light.” |
