Win $200,000 Playing Fantasy Baseball

Who Should I Draft?

Buster Posey or J.P. Arencibia

Buster Posey
Buster Posey (C/1B)
San Francisco
J.P. Arencibia
J.P. Arencibia (C)
Toronto
Expert Picks
100%
0%

Site Projections
RotoChamp

Al Mechior
CBS Sports

Staff Rankings
FFToolbox

Ryan Boyer
Rotoworld

Scott White
CBS Sports

Staff Rankings
ESPN

Ryan Fowler
Fox Sports

Joel Beall
Fox Sports

Dave McKay
The Fantasy Sports Brain

Alex Roberts
RotoBaller

John Halpin
Fox Sports

Andrew Eggers
Fantasy Couch

Terrance Bridgett
FantasyTrade411

Tristan Cockcroft
ESPN

Steve Gardner
USA Today

Matthew Berry
ESPN

Ryan Hodge
The Fantasy Bums

Wayne Bretsky
BretskyBall

Michael Sherman
Fantasy Team Advice

Jesse Sakstrup
The Hardball Times

Ryan Lester
Lesters Legends

Mike Podhorzer
FanGraphs

Luke Gloeckner
Mr. Cheatsheet

Josh Shepardson
Baseball Prospectus

Rudy Gamble
Razzball

Greg Smith
The Fake Baseball

Andrew Gould
Bleacher Report

Brandon Funston
Yahoo! Sports

Duncan Sanford
EDSBaseball

Kevin Hanson
EDSBaseball

Alan Harrison
The Fantasy Fix

Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports

Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports

Bryan Curley
Baseball Professor

Jordan Tozzi
Legion Report

Grey Albright
Razzball

Nick Raducanu
FantasyTrade411

Adam Meyer
Fox Sports

Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports

Nando Di Fino
CBS Sports

Michael Pichan
RotoInfo

Brien Bonneville
The Fake Baseball

Brad Evans
Yahoo! Sports

Igor Derysh
Sports Jerks

Michael Clifford
FantasyTrade411

Eno Sarris
FanGraphs

Jason Willan
The Fake Baseball

KJ
Fantasy Team Advice

Tony Mauriello
FantasyTrade411

Reggie Yinger
Baseball Press

Ben Pritchett
FantasySports.org

Davis Mattek
Sports Wunderkind

Jeff Boggis
Fantasy Sports Empires

Muntradamus
Beast Dome

R.J. White
Fantasy Baseball Cafe

David Gonos
DavidGonos.com

Hector Roman
HecmanRoto

Dan Clasgens
Get Sports Info

Brent Namejko
Fantasy Smack Talk

Neil Parker
The Fake Baseball

Mike Harmon
Swollen Dome

Tim Young
MLB Soup

Sablich Brothers
The New York Times

Joshua Kay
The Fantasy Fix

Staff Rankings
FFLockerRoom

Site Projections
NumberFire

No experts recommend J.P. Arencibia over Buster Posey

ECR
30
262
Best Rank
11
166
Worst Rank
82
301
Composite ADP
15
229
19
248
17
260
15
216

View Average Draft Position (ADP) for all players

Average Auction Value
$30
N/A

View Auction Values for all players

AB
516
383
RUNS
76
47
HITS
159
88
1B
104
48
2B
32
18
3B
2
1
HRS
21
20
RBI
91
58
SB
2
1
CS
1
0
BB
61
26
SO
90
114
AVE
.312
.230
OBP
.382
.281
SLG
.506
.443
OPS
.893
.725
AB
530
347
RUNS
78
45
HITS
178
81
1B
114
47
2B
39
16
3B
1
0
HRS
24
18
RBI
103
56
SB
1
1
CS
1
0
BB
69
18
SO
96
108
AVE
.336
.233
OBP
.412
.271
SLG
.549
.435
OPS
.957
.710

“Being a catcher isn't as big of an advantage as it used to be. Is he still worth it?”

 

“He's everything we once hoped Joe Mauer would be”

 

“On my all bust team. Read more at http://www.FantasySportsEmpires.com ”

 

“When you get Buster Posey, you have the best hitting catcher who will produce nearly every night at a very high level. Buster is the real deal, and is worth a high-draft pick to solidify the catcher position on your roster. Not only does he have 30 HR potential, he will hit over .325.”

“J.P. is a very underrated catcher coming into 2013 thanks to an injury that knocked him out of baseball for 2.5 months. J.P. has huge pop and is an easy candidate to hit 25+ HRs. His batting average does come with some downside, but already he is showing improvement as a player that can easily reach .250 any season now.”

“There's nothing not to like about Posey. He's head and shoulders ahead of every other Catcher. Plus, there's a good chance he'll get more playing time than any other catcher.”

 

“The clear-cut No. 1 catcher with first-base eligibility is just 25 and should only improve upon last season's MVP-worthy numbers. ”

 
 

“ton of power but BA suffers”

 
Buster Posey nearly leads comeback

CBS Sports | May 18th, 6:57pm
Giants catcher Buster Posey's solo home run in the eighth inning Friday against Colorado narrowed what...

J.P. Arencibia powers up for 10th homer

CBS Sports | May 16th, 3:12am
Blue Jays backstop J.P. Arencibia had another powerful performance on Wednesday during an 11-3 drubbing...

Arencibia hits 10th homer as Jays beat Giants - J.P. Arencibia | TOR

Rotoworld | May 16th, 3:05am
J.P. Arencibia hit his 10th home run Wednesday in the Blue Jays' 11-3 win over the Giants.