Win $200,000 Playing Fantasy Baseball

Who Should I Draft?

Andrew McCutchen or Matt Holliday

Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen (CF)
Pittsburgh
Matt Holliday
Matt Holliday (LF)
St. Louis
Expert Picks
100%
0%

Grey Albright
Razzball

Tristan Cockcroft
ESPN

Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports

Ryan Fowler
Fox Sports

David Gonos
DavidGonos.com

Ryan Hodge
The Fantasy Bums

Davis Mattek
Sports Wunderkind

Duncan Sanford
EDSBaseball

Adam Meyer
Fox Sports

Staff Rankings
ESPN

Staff Rankings
FFToolbox

Steve Gardner
USA Today

Mike Harmon
Swollen Dome

Eno Sarris
FanGraphs

Scott White
CBS Sports

Nando Di Fino
CBS Sports

Brandon Funston
Yahoo! Sports

Michael Clifford
FantasyTrade411

Joel Beall
Fox Sports

Jason Willan
The Fake Baseball

Andrew Gould
Bleacher Report

Igor Derysh
Sports Jerks

Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports

Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports

Kevin Hanson
EDSBaseball

John Halpin
Fox Sports

KJ
Fantasy Team Advice

Michael Sherman
Fantasy Team Advice

Neil Parker
The Fake Baseball

Matthew Berry
ESPN

Alan Harrison
The Fantasy Fix

Joshua Kay
The Fantasy Fix

R.J. White
Fantasy Baseball Cafe

Nick Raducanu
FantasyTrade411

Tim Young
MLB Soup

Sablich Brothers
The New York Times

Greg Smith
The Fake Baseball

Brien Bonneville
The Fake Baseball

Andrew Eggers
Fantasy Couch

Ryan Lester
Lesters Legends

Josh Shepardson
Baseball Prospectus

Jordan Tozzi
Legion Report

Tony Mauriello
FantasyTrade411

Jesse Sakstrup
The Hardball Times

Ben Pritchett
FantasySports.org

Dan Clasgens
Get Sports Info

Staff Rankings
FFLockerRoom

Rudy Gamble
Razzball

Alex Roberts
RotoBaller

Brad Evans
Yahoo! Sports

Reggie Yinger
Baseball Press

Hector Roman
HecmanRoto

Wayne Bretsky
BretskyBall

Site Projections
RotoChamp

Jeff Boggis
Fantasy Sports Empires

Ryan Boyer
Rotoworld

Bryan Curley
Baseball Professor

Brent Namejko
Fantasy Smack Talk

Terrance Bridgett
FantasyTrade411

Muntradamus
Beast Dome

Mike Podhorzer
FanGraphs

Dave McKay
The Fantasy Sports Brain

Luke Gloeckner
Mr. Cheatsheet

Al Mechior
CBS Sports

Michael Pichan
RotoInfo

Site Projections
NumberFire

No experts recommend Matt Holliday over Andrew McCutchen

ECR
8
36
Best Rank
3
17
Worst Rank
25
79
Composite ADP
7
44
7
43
11
55

View Average Draft Position (ADP) for all players

Average Auction Value
$36
$21

View Auction Values for all players

AB
577
565
RUNS
97
91
HITS
169
165
1B
105
102
2B
32
37
3B
5
1
HRS
25
25
RBI
89
95
SB
22
5
CS
9
3
BB
76
69
SO
120
115
AVE
.293
.291
OBP
.377
.374
SLG
.499
.493
OPS
.877
.867
AB
593
599
RUNS
107
95
HITS
194
177
1B
128
112
2B
29
36
3B
6
2
HRS
31
27
RBI
96
102
SB
20
4
CS
12
4
BB
70
75
SO
132
132
AVE
.327
.295
OBP
.398
.374
SLG
.553
.497
OPS
.953
.876

“25/25 skills are real but the '12 BA (.327) is likely to regress a bit”

“Mr. Rock Steady in a .300/25/100 kind of way”

“Can you trust his batting average?”

“One of the most underrated players in the game”

“Yet another five-category star at the position, his second-half struggles have some concerned. But the 26-year-old is worth the investment after making a huge jump into the top-tier last season. ”

 

“ Andrew McCutchen had a career year with Pittsburgh last season, and I see a lot of regression for 2013. Although still in growth mode at age 26, there is nothing in his stats to say that he is a 30 home run hitter. In fact, he is closer to a 20 home run hitter. My bigger concern for McCutchen is his stolen bases. He gets caught stealing more than you might think. Here is a breakdown of his numbers: SB CS SB% 33 10 77% 23 10 70% 20 12 63% ...”

 

“Does not get more Clutch than Cutch. In 2012 he showed the full package with a .327 Average that brought him 31 HRs/96 RBIs/20 SBs. He vows to steal more in 2013, but the power will likely not get any better. He is a rising star and 30/30 is more than possible.”

“While we want to think Holliday will continue to improve, at the age of 33 we may have seen his last days of hitting 30 HRs. You can draft him for that total in 2013, but just know after 27 in 2012 it is not likely to get much higher than that. ”

“McCutchen finshed 2011 with a .259 BA, hit .253 in last two months of 2012 while SB have declined each of the last three seasons (SB rate was just 63% in 2012)”

“Is there any player less recognized for his consistent production year in and year out?”

 
Andrew McCutchen doubles in fifth straight game

CBS Sports | Jun 15th, 4:51pm
Pittsburgh outfielder Andrew McCutchen doubled for the fifth consecutive game Friday in a 3-0 win against...

Matt Holliday gets Sunday off

CBS Sports | Jun 16th, 4:49pm
Cardinals outfielder Matt Holliday is out of the lineup Sunday against Miami, Fox Sports Midwest reports....